Skip to main content

Table 3 Comparison of the responses of institutions and entrustment workplace to major occupational roles in the evaluation items through simple logistic regression analysis

From: The roles of doctors, nurses, and industrial hygienists in the healthcare management services in Korea: a comparison of the opinions of specialized health management institutions and entrusted enterprises

Items Detailed items Doctor’ role Nurse’s role IH‘s role
O.R.***(95%CI§§§) O.R. (95%CI) O.R. (95%CI)
1.1 Guidance of work place health management
  1.1.1 The assessment for work fitness of workers with health problems identified by the HE¶ EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI§ 0.733(0.275, 1.956) 0.238*(0.098, 0.577) 0.900(0.165, 4.916)
1.1.2 Follow up of workers’ HE EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 1.000(0.384, 2.605) 0.805(0.240, 2.694) > 100(0.000, > 100)
1.1.3 Investigation of medical problems and guidance on the prevention of their recurrence EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 0.822(0.343, 1.968) 0.578(0.247, 1.350) 0.848(0.293, 2.460)
1.1.4 Participation rate of occupational health and safety committee EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 1.385(0.353, 5.427) 0.245*(0.100, 0.599) 0.857(0.349, 2.102)
1.1.5 Guidance on their wearing of PPEs†† EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 4.580*(1.452, 14.443) 3.858*(1.596, 9.323) 0.391(0.151, 1.016)
1.1.6 Guidance of improvement of WE# EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 3.333*(1.148, 9.675) 1.129(0.440, 2.902) 0.146*(0.04, 0.458)
1.1.7 Guidance of WTI‡‡ EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 6.329*(2.012, 19.906) 1.513(0.650, 3.519) 0.321*(0.119, 0.872)
1.1.8 Guidance on the formulation of plans on health education and the conduction EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 1.547(0.606, 3.946) 2.105(0.861, 5.149) 0.269*(0.111, 0.654)
1.2 Performance of prevention of occupational disease
  1.2.1 Management confirmation of substances used by process and MSDS EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 4.103(0.886, 19.008) 0.970(0.358, 2.625) 0.075*(0.017, 0.337)
1.2.2 Guidance of posting or keeping of MSDS and warning signs EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 4.462(0.545, 36.496) 1.776(0.703, 4.486) 0.034*(0.004, 0.265)
1.2.3 Guidance of investigation of risk factors of musculoskeletal disorders EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 1.594(0.668, 3.805) 0.218*(0.089, 0.535) 0.673(0.284, 1.595)
1.2.4 Guidance of campaigns to improve workers’ health EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 1.682(0.705, 4.013) 1.031(0.381, 2.793) 0.453(0.170, 1.208)
1.2.5 Guidance of prevention of job stress EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 1.455(0.622, 3.403) 0.481(0.176, 1.320) 0.524(0.182, 1.510)
1.2.6 Guidance of risk assessment of cerebro-cardiovascular risk EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 0.822(0.343, 1.968) 1.146(0.467, 2.812) 0.433(0.108, 1.737)
1.2.7 Guidance of programs of health process on CS** EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 6.656(0.835, 53.082) 0.358*(0.135, 0.951) 0.382*(0.152, 0.960)
1.2.8 Prevention of dust induced medical problems EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 8.826*(1.954, 39.871) 0.633(0.253, 1.586) 0.276*(0.102, 0.748)
1.2.9 Guidance of of HCP††† EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 3.523*(1.215, 10.214) 0.277*(0.115, 0.666) 0.673(0.284, 1.595)
1.3 Management of executory places of business EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 1.356(0.448, 4.105) 0.529(0.224, 1.250) 0.366*(0.154, 0.873)
1.4 Rate of accreditation of risk assessment EW 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref) 1.0(ref)
SI 1.441(0.282, 7.370) 0.000(0.000,) 0.129(0.050, 0.335)
  1. * p-value< 0.05, ‡ EW: Entrustment workplace, § SI: Specialized health management institution, IH: Industrial hygienist, ¶ HE: Health examination, # PPE: Personal protective equipment, †† WE: Work environment, ‡‡ WTI: Work through inspection, ** CS: Confined space, ††† HCP: Hearing conservation program, ***O.R.: Odds ratio, §§§95% CI: 95% Confidence interval