This study examined the correlations between hotel workers’ musculoskeletal symptoms and their occupational characteristics. Risk factors that contribute to the incidence of work-related musculoskeletal symptoms can be categorized into ergonomic risk factors, structural factors regarding the working environment, and individual factors (including gender and age). This study aimed to identify the relationship between work-related musculoskeletal disorders and risk factors, with a focus on structural working environment factors, and explored prevention methods.
The incidence of work-related musculoskeletal symptoms showed a significant difference between genders, as 104 males, 16.8% of all study subjects, reported symptoms, whereas 131 females (33.1%) did so. According to a study that surveyed the health status of Korean workers , a smaller number of female workers than their male counterparts have had their symptoms legally recognized as occupational injuries, yet female workers reported a 2.5 times higher incidence of work-related musculoskeletal disorders than males did. Another study on the incidence of musculoskeletal disorders and the public health management system  found that a significantly higher ratio of females reported work-related musculoskeletal symptoms than males did. Female workers have been known to be vulnerable to musculoskeletal disorders, but different studies cite different causes. One study, which examined 56 previous studies on work-related musculoskeletal disorders, noted that being a 'female’ was a risk factor for upper extremity musculoskeletal disorders, which stemmed from other work-related exposures, psychosocial factors, cultural factors, and biological differences . Some studies have shown that female workers are more exposed to factors such as layoffs due to corporate restructuring, early retirement, temporary employment and job insecurity than male counterparts , and thus suffer from greater job stress, whereas other research concluded the burden of juggling between work and family exacerbates musculoskeletal disorders . This study revealed, that in comparison to males, female workers endure more frequent shift work, longer weekly working hours, more intensive labor, and a shorter employment period (Table 2). Females suffer poorer working conditions than males do, which may have served as a risk factor for work-related musculoskeletal disorders. In the multivariate analysis, shift work and labor intensity had a statistically significant impact on the prevalence rate of work-related musculoskeletal symptoms only among female workers.
Among hotel workers in room and food and beverage departments, females reported a far higher prevalence of work-related musculoskeletal disorders. The gender disparity may have occurred because males and females in the same department perform different tasks under different job titles, creating discrepancies between risk factors for male and female workers. Female workers in the room department often arrange room reservations and guide customers and thus are exposed to emotional labor and long hours of standing up while working. On the other hand, males frequently serve as valet parkers, doormen, bellmen, porters who carry luggage, and limo-drivers. Hotels food and beverage departments, which primarily provide food and beverage services, employ managers and other personnel in management positions, as well as staff in sub-management positions such as room food servers, bartenders, and banquet servers. The sub-management employees stand up for long periods of time while working, serve food and beverages in unstable postures, and keep hotel halls clean. The waiters in the food and beverage department showed a relatively more equal division of labor between genders. However, the men primarily conducted work that carried lower ergonomic risk factors, including promoting banquet services, booking banquet reservations and management of banquet services. On the other hand, men working in the kitchen recorded a higher prevalence of work-related musculoskeletal disorders than women did. A multiple logistic regression analysis of males’ work-related musculoskeletal symptoms found that men in the working in kitchen were more than 1.9 times more likely to carry risks of musculoskeletal disorders than men working in the room department. Likewise, both males and females showed a difference in the prevalence rate of work-related musculoskeletal symptoms among departments. As a series of prior studies [25, 26] have discovered, males and females working for the same department seemed to have experienced different exposures to ergonomic risk factors because men and women are expected to perform different gender roles, causing a division of labor based on gender.
The hotel industry relies on shift work more frequently than other industries, because it needs to respond to customer inquiries 24 hours a day. Of the research subjects, 57.8% worked on a shift schedule, which was above the average of 29.9% among their European counterparts surveyed in 2007 . Survey research organizations in Korea and their sampling and weighting techniques vary significantly, resulting in a pool of partial, unreliable data on shift work. In three separate surveys , 50.0% of domestic hotels and restaurants said their operations were based on shift work in 2003, 0.3% in 2007, and 34.0% in 2011, showing extreme variations depending on the survey year. A similarly wide gap was observed in other polls on their working conditions , as 18.3% of respondents reported working on a shift schedule in 2006, but only 8.4% in 2010. This study’s subjects showed a higher ratio of workers on shift schedules compared with those of workers researched by other studies.
In this study, multiple logistic regression analysis revealed that women on shift schedules experienced statistically significantly higher numbers of work-related musculoskeletal symptoms. Research that found a relationship between shift work and musculoskeletal symptoms [30, 31] outnumbered research that did not find such a relationship . Shift work also increased work-related musculoskeletal disorders in a statistically significant manner, according to a retrospective cohort study . One study observed that public health and medical workers’ musculoskeletal disorders increased in proportion to shift work, because shift work reduced relaxation hours and increased working hours . In addition, a study of 1,163 nurses discovered that work-related musculoskeletal disorders were twice as common in a group of nurses who worked on a shift for two weeks or longer a month than a group of those who worked on a shift for shorter periods . The hotel industry finds it impossible to completely eliminate shift work. Nonetheless hotels need to seek ways to minimize shift work to reduce the occurrence of work-related musculoskeletal disorders, as this study has demonstrated that the accommodation businesses have reported a higher ratio of workers on shift schedules.
The hotels’ higher reliance on shift work, at the same time, is also likely to cause sleep deprivation . A lack of sleep has proven to induce physiological dysfunction and build up fatigue, a major cause of sleepiness during working and subsequent accidents, as well as increasing risks of employees’ work efficiency loss and accidents . 47.5% of research subjects, or 483 people, felt dissatisfied with their sleep, and this group reported a statistically significantly higher number of work-related musculoskeletal symptoms than the group of workers who felt satisfied with their sleep. Multiple logistic regression analysis yielded a similar result, as the risk of work-related musculoskeletal symptoms more than doubled in both males and females who were dissatisfied with their sleep. Another study also concluded that sleep disorders weaken the capacity for physical recovery and diminish pain tolerance, inducing subjective pain . However, this study had a cross-sectional design, and thus was capable of establishing an association between sleep satisfaction and work-related musculoskeletal symptoms, but incapable of verifying a causal relationship. One study set pain as an independent variable and sleep disorders as a dependent variable and demonstrated a statistically significant association, indicating a reverse causal relationship in which musculoskeletal pain causing sleep dissatisfaction could exist . Further research is required to establish a causal relationship between sleep satisfaction and work-related musculoskeletal symptoms.
In this study, 421 workers, or 41.4%, belonged to the group of high work intensity, and both males and females in this group experienced a significantly higher incidence of work-related musculoskeletal symptoms. However, multiple logistic regression analysis, which weighs all variables, revealed that only females of the high work intensity group displayed a statistically significant incidence of work-related musculoskeletal symptoms (Table 4). Another study of hotel workers reached a similar conclusion, that the group of workers whose duties increased per hour reported a higher odds ratio of prevalence of work-related musculoskeletal symptoms than the group of workers with no hourly increase in duties . Korean workers have faced a greater risk of musculoskeletal disorders since 1997, when Korea sought a bailout from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) during the height of the Asian financial crisis and the ensuing recession. The economic turmoil put workers under the pressure of more intensive labor, reduced break time due to overtime or extra work, and more frequent shift work and increased occupational stress. The hotel industry started cutting costs through layoffs and outsourcing. Following the financial crisis, 27 five-star hotels in Seoul reduced their combined workforce from 16,400 to 14,800 employees .
The leading musculoskeletal risk factors in the hotel business are repetitive motion, excessive force, and unnatural and static postures. Hotel workers are exposed to repetitive motion while preparing or cooking food, dishwashing, and changing beds. Hotel workers are exposed to excessive force when lifting heavy luggage, transporting and reloading ingredients, serving customers, and cleaning. Hotel workers are exposed to unnatural postures as they become constrained by the height of the front desk while receiving customers or performing VDT tasks, and by confined space while cleaning and rearranging bathrooms. Hotel employees’ are exposed to the static postures of standing up without any moving for a prolonged time at the front desk when standing by . Hotel workers are exposed to a variety of ergonomic risk factors simultaneously, and in a survey performed outside Korea , more than 60% of workers at hotels and restaurants reported three or more symptoms of pain, and only 16% of the respondents felt no symptoms. As demonstrated above, hotel workers are already exposed to many musculoskeletal risk factors, and therefore the shortage of workers increases the labor intensity of the current workforce, further aggravating their musculoskeletal disorders. One study examined the relationship between labor intensity and work-related musculoskeletal disorders among workers who perform standardized tasks in the shipbuilding sector  and another study in the automobile sector . A study in Korea targeted workers responsible for public facility management, who often conduct non-standardized tasks like hotel workers do. The research found that workers in the public facility management sector underwent restructuring following the financial crisis and structural changes in their working environment, such as lower numbers of co-workers and an increased workload from 1998 to 2000, and after such changes, the workers showed statistically significantly greater odds of having work-related musculoskeletal symptoms . A prospective study on Finnish workers in the public sector also showed that restructuring compelled workers to perform more intensive physical labor, thus intensifying their work-related musculoskeletal symptoms . The Korean hotel industry has seen a steady expansion of restructuring and outsourcing practices since the Asian financial crisis, and in the process hotel employees have endured an increased workload and pressure to perform extra labor. Therefore, structural factors need to be improved in a way that augments the working environment to ensure that working conditions and labor intensity do not deteriorate, in addition to the need to address ergonomic risk factors .
The first limitation of this study is that we did not examine workers dispatched by outsourcing companies to the hotel industry even though they are likely to be exposed to the risk factors of musculoskeletal disorders. According to an assessment of five-star hotels in Seoul in 2005 , employees dispatched by outsourcing companies accounted for as much high as 36.3% of the workforce. 26% of room maids at the five-star hotels were dispatched workers, and the proportion of dispatched workers also stood at more than 20% at the cleaning and equipment management divisions. This study analyzed 1,016 workers, and only 53 workers, or 5.2%, were in charge of housekeeping. Many five-star hotels hire full-time housekeepers to clean floors reserved for VIP customers, but other floors for general customers are cleaned by dispatched workers . Likewise, this study analyzed only full-time housekeepers, and did not include dispatched housekeepers. Housekeeping, cleaning and equipment management are dismissed as simple manual labor, and thus employees in these three divisions, who are hired by outsourcing companies, are likely to be exposed to risk factors for musculoskeletal disorders. This means the study’s result may not represent work-related musculoskeletal disorders of all workers. The second limitation of this study is that the research did not target all hotels in Seoul, and therefore it is difficult to generalize this study’s conclusions to a national level. The third limitation of this study is that a self-administered survey was performed to analyze work-related musculoskeletal symptoms and absence or early leaves, relying on respondents’ recollection of their experience in the previous year, and thus leaving a possibility of memory bias and overstatements. The final limitation of this study was that the research was a cross-sectional study and thus inadequate for identifying a causal association between independent variables and dependent variables. The analysis of a causal relationship between the abovementioned factors requires a prospective study.
Despite these limitations, this study is a valuable addition to the scarce research on musculoskeletal disorders of hotel workers. This study conducted gender stratification analysis to identify the prevalence rates of work-related musculoskeletal symptoms and general and occupational traits of hotel workers across all departments. This study also analyzed relevant factors to provide essential data needed for developing precautionary measures against work-related musculoskeletal symptoms.
This study focused on structural risk factors regarding the working environment, such as the gender-based division of labor, shift work and labor intensity, which demonstrated a statistically significant correlation with the work-related musculoskeletal symptoms of hotel workers. Both gender groups of men and women reported different prevalence rates of work-related musculoskeletal symptoms among different departments. This could indicate gender-based division of labor produces different ergonomic risk factors for different gender groups. However, only females displayed a statistically significant correlation between shift work and labor intensity and musculoskeletal symptoms. Minimizing ergonomic risk factors alone does not suffice to effectively prevent musculoskeletal diseases among hotel workers. Instead, work assignments should be based on gender and department, and working hours and work intensity should be adjusted to address multi-dimensional musculoskeletal risk factors. In addition, an approach that seeks to minimize shift work is needed to reduce the incidence of musculoskeletal disorders.